Review: Tom Hardy Lifts ‘The Drop’ Out of Crime Drama Mediocrity

By September 12, 2014

If you’re a fan of adorable things happening in grim settings, you should know that Tom Hardy adopts a puppy in The Drop, an average crime drama that is otherwise serious and not at all puppy-like. Although he does find the puppy in a garbage can, which is more in line with the rest of the movie’s gloominess.

Hardy is the standout in this mediocre offering, a posh, London-born actor playing a lowly Brooklyn bartender with the authenticity of a native. It isn’t just the accent (though that’s harder to get right than a lot of actors make it seem) but the mannerisms, the vocal tics, that make his character — named Bob Saginowski, of course — come to life.

The Drop 3

Bob works at a dive called Cousin Marv’s Bar, owned by a typical blue-collar striver named Marv (James Gandolfini) who actually does happen to be Bob’s cousin. Like many Brooklyn bars (or so we are led to understand), Cousin Marv’s has in recent years come under the control of Chechen mobsters, who use it as a money-laundering operation. A frustrated Marv has little choice but to go along with it, while Bob tries to keep his head down and his nose clean. Bob don’t want no trouble.

Two unrelated things happen that bring trouble to Bob anyway. One is that Cousin Marv’s is robbed by masked gunmen (“Do you know whose money you’re jackin’ here?” Marv asks in disbelief), which brings the unwelcome attention of a nosy police detective (John Ortiz). The other thing is that Bob finds a pit bull puppy, abused and whimpering, in a garbage can outside the home of a young woman named Nadia (Noomi Rapace), who most certainly did not put the poor li’l fella there and is as appalled about it as Bob is. Bob and Nadia become tentative friends, and we wait to see how this cute development figures in to the larger story (don’t worry, it does).

A seemingly humble man of few words and little education, Bob has a Rocky Balboa vibe about him (which is enhanced by his chaste courtship of the bookish Nadia), plus a little of Brando’s Terry Malloy from On the Waterfront. And like the pit bull puppy he rescued, Bob is subject to prejudicial assumptions about his character when in fact violent tendencies are a matter of nurture, not nature. The nosy detective is savvy enough to know that Cousin Marv’s is connected to the Chechens, and subsequent grisly developments turn up the heat on everyone professing innocence or ignorance. The question is whether Bob is smart enough to stay out of the whole mess.

The Drop 4

It comes from a short-story-turned-screenplay by Dennis Lehane, a crime novelist whose work has been turned into movies before (Mystic River, Gone Baby Gone) but who has not adapted his own work until now. As you might expect from a screenplay based on a short story — adapted by a first-time screenwriter, no less — The Drop is formulaic and simple, uninterested in breaking new ground, or even in treading the old ground in a new way. The director, Belgium’s Michael R. Roskam (whose stellar Bullhead was Oscar-nominated a few years ago), tells the story capably but without distinction.

No, it’s Tom Hardy who makes The Drop worth seeing (or at least not worth actively avoiding), aided by the late James Gandolfini in a Tony Soprano-ish role that should evoke fond smiles from all who remember him. Gandolfini is in his element, of course; the chameleonic Hardy is far out of his, yet delivers an impressively heartfelt and natural performance. The power to turn a so-so script into a half-decent movie with nothing but one’s own acting prowess and personal magnetism is a mighty power indeed.

The following two tabs change content below.
Eric D. Snider
Eric has been a film critic since 1999, and a beard wearer since 2008. He holds a degree in journalism and used to work in "the newspaper industry," back when that was a thing.
  • Thomas Leath

    I’d be very interested in how you rate Gandolfini’s performance. Thoughts?

  • Rob Donofrio

    I agree about the script being so-so at best. I actually think that Tom Hardy was totally miscast and made the movie even less than so-so. Like Eric, I immediately thought about Rocky watching this. It’s like he said to himself, how can I pretend to be from Brooklyn? I’ll just act like Rocky Balboa. Sure Philadelphia is close enough……..but Rocky wasn’t smart……especially in the first few Rocky movies which is what the character reminded me of. So sometimes, Hardy’s character acted dumb, and talked like Rocky. Other times, he seemed smart and calculating and talked almost normal. I lived in New York the first 21 years of my life. My parents and grandparents are from Brooklyn and I went there often. I’ve never met anyone who acted like Rocky or Tom Hardy’s character ever. People should skip this movie and watch Gandolfini in Killing Them Softly. That movie was 100 times better and had a realistic script. Scooter Mcnairy’s character was amazing. Although odd….he managed to be a realistic and entertaining character. The type of guy that I would run into in Brooklyn (or a big city like Detroit which is the city of Killing Them Softly) He fits in these type of movies. I have no idea how this movie has such positive reviews. I’m the target audience for something like this and It was disaster.